yes...LEDs look good. I have also found that the controller has to be power cycled before it will come back up and see the new solo. I just tried again...same results

.
So I have solo1 and solo2 working on controller1...prompts to press A+B when different solo is powered up when controller is powered up...that is all good. Below is how I am next trying to pair to controller2.
With all powered down, power up solo1, power up controller2...WAITING FOR SOLO displays. At this point I press the PAIR button on solo1 for 1 second. Within a few seconds, the display shows NEW DEVICE FOUND PRESS A+B START PAIRING. I press A+B, solo pairs, everything is great...solo1 appears to now be paired with controller2
and controller1.
The problem: I now power everything off. Power up solo1, power up
controller1...WAITING FOR SOLO displays...and it never changes...it is not seeing solo1. If I now press the PAIR button solo1...it pairs right up with controller1. But now, if I power everything down, power up solo1 and controller2...solo1 is not seen by controller2. It's like when I use the PAIR button to pair with controller1, it kills the pairing with controller2...and vice versa.
Sorry for the rant...but wanted to get the procedure written out so maybe someone can help.