Drone collision with helicopter

Joined
Jun 18, 2017
Messages
116
Reaction score
26
Location
Philadelphia
This is not good for the drone hobbyist. Collision with helicopter. Screenshot_2018-02-16-01-04-26-1.png

content://media/external/file/29951
 
Joined
Dec 29, 2017
Messages
25
Reaction score
3
Age
38
I think the instructor is going to have to take all the blame for this one.
 
Joined
Dec 29, 2017
Messages
25
Reaction score
3
Age
38
At a quick glance, looks like a decent place to fly, there are only two hospital heliports nearby*.

*One hospital heliport is 2 miles away, the other is 4 miles away.

Not sure why the instructor didn't just go up considering he was only 50 feet above the tree line. Going up seems to be the logical move if you encounter a drone in a helicopter.

Google Maps

DANIEL ISLAND, SC (WCSC) -

Federal authorities are investigating a helicopter crash that happened Wednesday near the southern tip of Daniel Island.

A Robinson R22 helicopter struck a tree and crash-landed Wednesday afternoon, according to Federal Aviation Administration spokesperson Kathleen Bergen.

Charleston Police met with the two passengers of the crash later that afternoon, according to an incident report.

The instructor told police he is a private helicopter instructor and was giving a lesson to a student pilot at approximately 3:30 p.m. While the student was practicing "low impact and hover taxi maneuvers" above undeveloped land on Daniel Island, they turned and saw a white "DJI Phantom quad-copter" drone headed into their airspace, the report states.

Police say the instructor took controls of the helicopter to avoid the drone and while attempting to land, the helicopter's tail rudder struck a small tree, causing him to lose control of the helicopter.

The instructor was able to land the helicopter on its rear landing skids but it turned over on its side, the report states.

The instructor notified the owner of the helicopter and FAA investigators.

The student told police they were about 50 feet above the tree line when the drone entered their fly space. She said when the helicopter struck the tree, several pieces of the helicopter hit surrounding brush causing the helicopter to turn on its side when it landed.

The FAA is investigating the incident.

No injuries were reported.
 
Joined
Dec 27, 2017
Messages
231
Reaction score
48
Age
49
To sum it up- it should be noted to all that fly.... YOU BETTER WATCH YOUR OWN TAIL ;)
 
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
892
Reaction score
202
Age
54
As best as I can understand it, the drone never made contact with the chopper. The "instructor" crashed on his own basically. To me this is the equivalent of a driver of a car blaming a cat on the side of the road for his crash into a pole.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: daniel s

EZL

Joined
May 24, 2017
Messages
231
Reaction score
33
Location
Central Illinois
For real, or just more hype!!??
This link may put things in perspective.
This fella got in trouble flying a quadcopter a few years ago and is not allowed to fly RCs. I think he is located in the UK and is one fella
that likes to hype things up.
 
Joined
May 8, 2017
Messages
1,205
Reaction score
621
Location
Portland Oregon
A Robinson R22 helicopter struck a tree and crash-landed
So a drone didn't not cause the helicopter to crash, bad piloting and human error led to the helicopter striking a tree which resulted in a crash.

"low impact and hover taxi maneuvers" above undeveloped land on Daniel Island, they turned and saw a white "DJI Phantom quad-copter" drone headed into their airspace
So a flight instructor is supposed to "teach" you to fly with ROOM to avoid accidents. If flying in a canyon for instance, they will not instruct you to fly down the center of the canyon, they will actually instruct you to fly to one side (this gives you lots of room to perform a 180 if needed). If flying low, they will not instruct you to fly "low and slow", instead they will instruct you to fly "low and fast" in order to give you enough immediate power should you need to climb unexpectedly.
It seems that this helicopter pilot who was instructing someone on hover taxi maneuvers did so in a location where neither themselves nor their student could avoid an accident in an emergency situation.

the helicopter's tail rudder struck a small tree, causing him to lose control of the helicopter.
Again, crash caused by pilot’s poor judgement and lack of situational awareness. For instance, if you are turning into a parking space in your car and you scrape the side of a parked car, that is your fault for not knowing where your corners are, the width of your car and it's turning radius. In this case the pilot maneuvered his craft without knowing where the surrounding objects where in relation to his tail rotor.

The student told police they were about 50 feet above the tree line when the drone entered their fly space.
So why was a student pilot practicing hovering 50 feet above a tree line when it would have been safer to practice hovering above an empty lot or field (which would have offered an immediate safe non object filled landing site).

In short, all evidence points to this being the work of a poor pilot with poor judgment and poor decision making abilities. Considering the downforce that helicopter rotor wash can produce, should the drone have been coming "straight at them" a simple rise in elevation would have blown the "dji phantom" to the ground or away from the copter. Should it have been coming at them from below, the same applies. If the drone was approaching from above the pilot could have simply descended and landed his copter and avoided a potential accident HAD the pilot or instructor been practicing hovering maneuvers in a safe and clear area (such as a barren lot or empty field).

The real culprit in this situation however is the scourge of many drone pilots. Once again TREE'S have caused a very serious accident. The FAA should immediately ban this instructor from ever teaching in a helicopter again and then proceed on a lengthy and vigorous tree cutting operation.
 
Joined
May 2, 2016
Messages
269
Reaction score
118
I'm not sure, but I belive there may - just may - have been other incident of R22s crashing....I don't think copter type drones were even flying when the first R22s started crashing.

Try your preferred open source online encyclopedia for a good summary of the history of the R22.

Small is not always beautiful.
 

New Threads

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
11,991
Messages
140,345
Members
13,918
Latest member
gpang.btr